Skip to main content

We are currently experiencing problems with card and online payments via our Capita Pay360 service. We apologise for any inconvenience and will advise once normal service has been restored.

Factors determining a nuisance

We follow case law and common law in deciding whether an incident counts as a statutory nuisance.

Some of the key factors we have to consider are;

  • does the problem affect a person’s enjoyment and use of their property? The problem must be considerable, and not just because the person making the complaint is sensitive
  • does the problem make it hard for somebody to enjoy a comfortable life? For example, does it stop them getting a good night’s sleep? We have to take into account the time the noise occurs, the area in which you live and any precautions taken to minimise the disturbance
  • is the problem caused by a normal household activity, such as shutting doors or walking up and downstairs? If so, it’s unlikely to count as a statutory nuisance
  • does the nuisance cross a boundary and affect somebody’s enjoyment of their property? Visual eyesores like overgrown gardens do not count as statutory nuisances. However, officers may be able to deal with such problems informally
  • does the problem occur regularly or is it continuous? Isolated problems, such as one-off parties or bonfires do not count as statutory nuisances unless they are extreme
  • is it unusual in the area where you live? If it is common, it is unlikely to count as a statutory nuisance
  • if the problem stems from a trade or business, have they employed all best practicable means to minimise it?
  • if the problem is light-related, does that light come from a transport premises or somewhere else with a high need for safety and security? If so, it does not count as a statutory nuisance
  • does it harm somebody’s health?
  • is the problem stemming from crown property? Nuisance laws do not usually apply here
  • is the problem serious? We cannot take trivia into account when determining nuisance

Some examples of what could be considered a statutory nuisance;

  • accumulations of refuse or rubbish must be considerable and pose some health threat such as the attraction of vermin
  • smells must materially affect the comfortable enjoyment of a person’s home. They must therefore be intrusive. Agricultural smells in a country location will not be considered a nuisance unless excessive (usually due to bad agricultural practices)
  • noise in the street relates only to noise from car radios, car alarms, machinery and equipment in the street
  • it is your basic right to enjoy your home peacefully, but there is no right to total silence
Is there anything wrong with this page?